Preview: sample stories and placeholder figures. Not yet published.

Is AI actually making life better for the people and places you love?

We check, and we keep score.

Certified Good is an independent publication that reports on AI projects of every kind, weighs the good each one does against its real cost, and certifies the best. Good intentions that fall short get an honest look too.

The Four-Generation Test

Does it help the people we love?

Before we score anything, we ask one question across four generations. Every take we publish answers it.

  1. ParentsDoes it help the people who raised us?
  2. MeDoes it help me, at work and at home?
  3. KidsDoes it help our kids grow up well?
  4. GrandkidsWill it help the world they inherit?
How every story is made

Everyone says AI will change the world. We check what it actually changed.

How we weigh it →
  1. 01 · FindFrom people, not press releasesStories come from the people doing the work and the people it affects. Anyone can send us one.
  2. 02 · ReportNamed sources, labeled evidenceWe interview the builders, the users and at least one critic, and mark every number as independent or self-reported.
  3. 03 · WeighEvery project, same rubricWe each score the good it does against its real cost, from 0 to 10, with the Four-Generation Test as our guide. Both scores get published.
  4. 04 · CertifyThe best earn Certified GoodProjects whose average score is above 8.0 earn the mark. It can't be bought, and it's reviewed again over time.

More stories

All stories →
Inaugural edition · [Month Year]

The Top 10, by our scores

See all ten →
Each pick is one program, not a verdict on the whole organization.Independent studychecked by outside researchersOrganization-reportedtheir numbers, not yet checked
  1. 1Lund University (MASAI trial)Independent studyAI-supported mammography found more cancers in a randomized trial of about 106,000 women.[x.x]/10
  2. 2Kaiser PermanenteOrganization-reportedAI scribes took hours of paperwork off physicians across millions of visits.[x.x]/10
  3. 3Jacaranda HealthOrganization-reportedAI-assisted texts answer thousands of questions a day from Kenyan mothers, with humans checking replies.[x.x]/10

Two people, one question

Two people, not an algorithm, choose and score every story. We both work in tech, we don't always agree, and we say so up front.

Why we're doing this →
Jeremiah SmithCo-founder, editor. Builds and sells AI at SnippetSentry, the Carolina Cyber Network and CallEmme Digital Safety.
Ed CarrollCo-founder. 20+ years in cybersecurity, higher education and tech. Doctoral student studying how institutions adapt to AI.